The 10 Best Bay Rum Aftershave – Buying Guide (2022 Bestsellers)

The best bay rum aftershave is a need for every shave. It’s becoming more and more common to see bay rum in men’s aftershave products these days.

It dates back to the 16th century in the West Indies, making it one of the oldest aftershaves smells still in use today.

Moreover, it was the most popular aftershave in the world until nearly a century ago.

As the popularity of bay rum rises, it becomes clear why. It has a manly aroma of cloves and spices, yet it’s not dated.

 PRODUCTDETAILSSHOP
Captain's Choice Bay Rum from Illinois

Captain's Choice Bay Rum from Illinois

  • Brand: Captain's Choice
  • Scent: Bay Rum(Pack of 1).
  • Item Form: Liquid
Buy Now
St. John's Bay Rum Cologne and Aftershave

St. John's Bay Rum Cologne

  • Brand: St Johns
  • Scent: Bay Rum
  • Item Form: Liquid
Buy Now
Nebraska's Blue Electricity Ogallala Bay Rum

Nebraska's Blue Electricity Ogallala Bay Rum

  • Brand: Ogallala Bay Rum
  • Scent: Bay Rum Regular Scent Aftershave.
  • Item Weight: 8 Ounces
Buy Now
Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave

Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave

  • Brand: Barberry Coast Shave Co.
  • Scent : Bay Rum.
  • Item Weight: 7 Ounces
Buy Now
Gilbert Henry Bay Rum Aftershave Balm

Gilbert Henry Bay Rum Aftershave Balm

  • Brand: Gilbert Henry
  • Advantages: After a little sting, you'll feel a pleasant cooling.
Buy Now
Gabels Bay Rum Aftershave

Gabels Bay Rum Aftershave

  • Brand: Gabels
  • Item Weight: 16 Ounces.
  • Item Form: Lotion
Buy Now
Taylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum

Taylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum

  • Brand: Taylor of Old Bond Street
  • Item Form: Lotion.
  • Item Weight: 0.15 Kilograms
Buy Now
Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

  • Brand: Clubman
  • Item Form: Liquid.
  • Item Weight: 12 Ounces
Buy Now
Grand Bay Bay Rum

Grand Bay Bay Rum

  • Brand: Grand Bay
  • Item Volume: 8 Fluid Ounces.
  • Item Form: Oil
Buy Now
Master Bay Rum Aftershave

Master Bay Rum Aftershave

  • Brand: Well Master
  • Scent: Bay Rum.
  • Item Form: Lotion
Buy Now

Best Bay Rum Aftershave Reviews:

1. Captain’s Choice Bay Rum from Illinois – Editor’s Choice

Captain's Choice Bay Rum from Illinois

With a name like Captain’s Choice, you can expect a classic ambiance.

When used, it produces a moderate alcoholic burn, but not a searing one. When you’re done shaving, you’ll feel nice and toasty.

The bay rum’s scent is softened by cinnamon, allspice, and a smidge of citrus.

This best bay rum aftershave has a more typical bay rum aroma than others, but it’s less clove-y.

Although the ingredients may not be what you’d anticipate, this meal nevertheless tastes great even if you’re not expecting it.

PROS

  • When applied to the skin, it is quite pleasant to the touch.
  • Witch hazel and glycerin counteract the effects of alcohol on the skin.

CONS

  • Don’t anticipate the same old bay rum flavor.

Verdict:

In terms of quality, you can be sure that it was made by Scott himself, and the bottle is a work of art in its own right.

Captain’s Choice offers six aftershaves to pick from if you’re seeking something different.

2. St. John’s Bay Rum Cologne and Aftershave – Best Premium

St. John's Bay Rum Cologne and Aftershave

Those who are familiar with St. John’s Bay Rum may recognize the unusual bottle with its ‘fishnet’ cover that has been around since just after World War II.

The St. John formula is best described as “subtle.” Even though it contains alcohol, the sensation is more like a tickle than a burn, and it’s easy to apply. Moreover, the perfume is well-balanced.

Furthermore, the woody scent of bay rum blends harmoniously with the spicy and aromatic tones of cinnamon and clove in this perfume.

PROS

  • With a dash of bay rum, it smells much like your father and grandfather used to wear.
  • This light scent was well-balanced and not overpowering in any way.
  • Cologne and aftershave in one bottle.

CONS

  • The absence of a moisturizing option is almost too commonplace.
  • It’s a hefty price.

Verdict:

As an aftershave and scent in one, St. John’s best bay rum cologne may be worth your money.

Because the fragrance of bay rum fades quickly, it’s a good idea to have an extra bottle on hand.

3. Nebraska’s Blue Electricity Ogallala Bay Rum – Best Budget

Nebraska's Blue Electricity Ogallala Bay Rum

Ogallala Bay Rum, from Ogallala, Nebraska, has a broad variety of flavors.

Even though there isn’t much of a burn to be felt rather it’s more like a warning that you over-shaved, it doesn’t hurt.

Cinnamon and bay rum scents are the most prevalent. Just a few minutes after being applied, it’s ready to get to work.

After usage, Ogallala’s witch hazel helps to keep skin moisturized by replenishing moisture lost via perspiration and alcohol.

PROS

  • It’s a great burn; it’s heated without being uncomfortable.
  • The scent of cinnamon, bay leaves, and cloves fill the air.
  • Bottle in blue with a striking pattern.

CONS

  • There’s no dabber to be found at this location.

Verdict:

The name speaks for itself, and there are six various aftershaves to choose from, not just bay rum.

A common component in all six is bay rum, yet each has a distinct flavor profile.

4. Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave – Best Value

Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave

For a change of pace, try this aftershave instead of your regular.

Glycerin helps to hydrate and smooth the skin while reducing the sting’s intensity and duration compared to other products. If you’ve got sensitive skin, this is a fantastic option.

Initially, the scents of orange and bay rum predominate, but as time goes on, the six primary aromas of cinnamon, vanilla, bay leaf, cloves, and allspice begin to emerge.

The scent may linger in the air for up to three hours. You can see it, yet it isn’t so intense that it distracts.

PROS

  • It isn’t overbearing, and it doesn’t smell.
  • Moisture retention in clothing is greatly improved when using this fabric.
  • An attractive bottle like this one might be placed on a bathroom counter.

CONS

  • It’s a little bottle, but it is cheap.

Verdict:

Despite the lack of any actual barberries in the dish, you can’t help but like its pirate-y name.

It’s hard to believe that Barberry Coast is just a few years old. This is an excellent choice.

5. Gilbert Henry Bay Rum Aftershave Balm – Best Formula

Gilbert Henry Bay Rum Aftershave Balm

For those who like a balm rather than a splash, this aftershave has an opaque consistency that is more like a lotion; it’s also a little more pronounced in aroma.

No greasy residue is left behind, even though the substance has a thick, gooey consistency.

Aloe vera, coconut oil, and glycerin help nourish the skin, while witch hazel and willow bark extract soothe irritation and redness, and neem oil fights germs and microbes.

Aromatically, it’s reminiscent of bay rum, but with a stronger clove note.

PROS

  • Those with sensitive skin should avoid this product.
  • You must try this one if you’re a fan of woody scents!
  • After a little sting, you’ll feel a pleasant cooling.

CONS

  • Expensive when weighed against the benefits received.
  • There are times when liquids are preferred.

Verdict:

There’s hardly much rum in this. If you want to soothe your skin, this is an excellent lotion.

6. Gabels Bay Rum Aftershave – Best Scent

Gabels Bay Rum Aftershave

This best bay rum aftershave has a pleasant alcohol burn and a little scent to help you get going again after shaving.

Aromatically, the scent is simple yet powerful, with a strong combination of bay and clove.

You won’t have any troubles with your skin after using it.

However, it is geared towards barbershops differently: by sheer volume.

PROS

  • Traditional bay rum has a clean, fresh scent.
  • Alcoholic sobriquet burn, that isn’t so.
  • If you’re a fan, you can often get a gallon for about $10.

CONS

  • It’s possible that this is excessively simple or basic.

Verdict:

If you’re a fan of barbershop scent, then this is the one.

7. Taylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum – Best Quality

Taylor of Old Bond Street Bay Rum

Prepare yourself for a significant increase in your blood alcohol level.

Upon application, the aroma is moderate yet spicy, with notes of clove and citrus.

After an hour or two, the scent begins to fade, so keep the bottle nearby if you want to preserve it.

Due to the lack of a moisturizing agent, those with dry or sensitive skin should exercise caution.

PROS

  • One of the most well-known and respected companies in the field.
  • It’s a light cologne or aftershave.
  • This is a great way to get energized.

CONS

  • Despite the bottle’s resemblance to glass, it is in fact plastic.

Verdict:

If you know your aftershave, you will love every bit of this one.

8. Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum – Best Design

Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

After applying it, you’ll feel a burning sensation on your rough portions and a cooling sensation across the rest of your body.

To begin, the scent is citrus and gradually settles into notes of bay rum (clove and cinnamon), as well as other spices.

Even though it quickly disappears, it tends to reappear after a period of absence.

The list of components, on the other hand, raises some red flags.

In addition to the familiar alcohol, water, and fragrances, there is a slew of other substances with long chemical names that might be confusing at first glance.

PROS

  • Has a long-lasting fragrance and is easy to use.
  • You can smell, taste, and even feel the burn of bay rum.
  • Because of its shape and labeling, the bottle looks elegant on the shelf.

CONS

  • A plastic bottle is all that’s inside, not a glass one.

Verdict:

You can tell this is an old-fashioned product with a pirate ship on top just by glancing at the bottle and label.

There’s something cheap and unattractive about using a plastic bottle as a vase.

Despite the little flaw, this is still an excellent product.

9. Grand Bay Bay Rum – Best Longevity

Grand Bay Bay Rum

This luxuriously subdued scent is dominated by a single note: bay rum. This combination has just three components: water, ethanol, and Dominica Bay tree oil.

Because it’s so simple, the scent only lasts for about 30 minutes until it fades away.

As a result of its high alcohol content, it leaves an unpleasant aftertaste.

There are no additional chemicals to tamp down the harshness of the alcohol in this lotion if you have sensitive or dry skin.

After using this product, you should always follow up with a moisturizer to maintain your skin healthy, regardless of your skin type.

PROS

  • Bay leaves have a strong scent.
  • You receive an 8 oz bottle.
  • Contains a light scent.

CONS

  • It’s all about you. It may be tiresome for some folks.

Verdict:

Grand Bay lime preserves the lovely simplicity of this cologne by just adding a whiff of lime.

In the hands of someone open to new ideas, it’s a fascinating blend.

10. Master Bay Rum Aftershave – Best Ingredients

Master Bay Rum Aftershave

If you’ve ever used an aftershave, you’ve probably experienced the stinging sensation caused by the alcohol in the formula.

Some aftershaves increase the kick factor, while others keep it at a more moderate level.

This last category includes Master Bay Rum. Applying the alcohol causes a little tingling sensation, but it does not cause any discomfort.

Ingredients are limited to water, alcohol, fragrances, and food coloring.

PROS

  • Bay rum that isn’t overwhelmed by other aromas or flavors.
  • Applying it is a pleasure.
  • Glycerin helps the skin retain moisture.
  • For the money you spend, you receive a lot of merchandise.

CONS

  • It’s possible that some drinkers prefer a stronger alcohol burn.

Verdict:

Glycerin, another common component in skin care products, aids in skin moisture retention, keeping it smooth and supple.

When it comes to post-shave care, this helps.

Choosing the Best Bay Rum Aftershave – Buyer’s Guide:

Best Bay Rum Aftershaves

An aftershave should have a lot of characteristics that you search for in a cologne.

For healthy skin, it is anticipated to promote cell regeneration.

Aftershave should be tested on your skin before purchase to ensure that it does not cause an allergic reaction and does not irritate the skin.

Because we now live in a digital age, this test is not always feasible.

Although it implies that you should walk into it blindly, this isn’t the case at all.

Instead, learn about your skin type and what products work best for you before deciding what to use.

Those with oily or regular skin should use a bay rum balm, on the whole (or those who live in humid climates).

People with dry skin should stay away from astringents and other products that contain a lot of alcohol.

Sensitive-skinned people should stick to unscented or bay oil-scented balms.

Most aftershaves using bay rum include alcohol. Disinfectants and anti-irritants are two of the most popular applications for this chemical.

If you use too much of it, your skin will feel like it’s on fire.

Consider these extra points as a result:

1. Fragrance:

When it comes to picking a smell, it’s not as simple as many think.

Perfume lingering time must also be taken into consideration. 

People’s scents often dissipate at different speeds. Due to individual differences in skin and body chemistry, certain scents have a distinctive scent on each guy.

It is common for high-quality bay rum aftershave to add essential oils that are used to produce distinctive smells. 

Dry skin, on the other hand, allows them to fade more rapidly.

Apply the aftershave to the parts of your face that tend to grow oily, such as the backs of your ears and the ridges of your temples.

The first thing you’ll notice about its scent is that it fades swiftly after application.

2. Eau De Parfum:

The quantity of aroma you leave behind when you enter a room is measured here. A plane’s trail may be compared to this.

From one to the next, the amount of perfume sillage a person might expect varies. Sillage is a point of pride for certain companies, but it’s not for everyone.

As you’ll see in the reviews, classic bay rum aftershaves have a distinctly masculine scent without being overpowering. 

Spiciness and warmth are evident in the Gilbert Henry Bay Rum balm.

It introduces the sandalwood and ylang-ylang infused base, with citrus and bay rum notes.

In the absence of testing, there is no way to determine the duration and range of a scent’s persistence. It’s simple to grasp because of the vocabulary utilized. 

3. Ingredients:

Using a too alcoholic aftershave has the opposite effect, as you’ve discovered so far.

Check the alcohol content as well as the presence of west Indian leaf extract/oil in the Bay Rum aftershave.

If you can locate bay leaves from the Caribbean or the Virgin Islands, the better.

In addition, have a look at the product’s chemical composition. Many aftershave products include chemicals.

It is impossible to avoid the usage of natural and chemical chemicals in the correct amounts.

If you have sensitive skin and want to drink bay rum, stick to the original recipe made with plant extracts, filtered water, and essential oils.

4. Hydrating Ingredients:

If you have dry skin, the perfume won’t stay very long. Hydrating ingredients like aloe vera, vitamin C, and glycerine should be included in an aftershave lotion.

Even if you don’t have dry skin, the aftershave’s SD-40, alcohol, and rum will dry and numb your skin to some degree.

Add moisturizing ingredients to mitigate these negative effects and boost the aftershave’s performance.

5. Price And Brand Familiarity:

We’ve highlighted some of the best brands in the industry in the following list, all of which use premium components.

Because they value their reputation, they go out of their way to provide consistently excellent quality work.

Therefore, high-quality ingredients are costly, which results in a high-priced end-product.

This compromise is the only way to acquire high-quality Bay Rum aftershave.

It’s important to note, however, that this does not mean you’ll have to shell out a significant chunk of money every few months.

A good bay rum aftershave may be obtained even if you’re strapped for cash.

Just be sure there are no harsh chemicals or excessive alcohol in the components.

What Is the Difference Between After-Shave Bay Rum Lotion and A Regular Post-Shave Lotion?

Best Bay Rum Aftershave

Most of the time, the two varieties of aftershaves serve the same purpose.

To find the best in the world, though, you must be aware of a few differences. The first consideration is the quality of the components.

Alcoholic aftershaves and water-based aftershaves are the two most common varieties of regular aftershaves.

Companies who manufacture bay rum aftershave use rum and extracts from West Indian bay leaves, as opposed to the former two options.

The tingling sensation subsides in a matter of seconds owing to these two ingredients.

Another notable difference is the smell. Bay rum aftershave comes in a variety of scents, with some being stronger than others.

The complexity of the following recipes is accentuated by the use of citrus, cinnamon, and cloves.

Depending on the other ingredients, the aroma may be earthy or woody.

While regular aftershaves are full of synthetic fragrances and linger for a long time, this is not the case with this product.

They lack the natural essence of a Bay Rum aftershave.

Frequently Asked Questions:

What Does Bay Rum Aftershave Smell Like?

This is a complicated issue with many viable solutions. However, to give you an idea of what to anticipate, imagine the West Indian bay, which is known for its spices.

The aroma of a dish may be considerably influenced by the use of oils from various spice mixes.

However, most women describe the perfume of bay rum as smelling as spicy cupcakes’ and ‘thanksgiving’.

Can I Use Aftershave as a Cologne?

If you’re going to use aftershave, you’re going to apply it in the morning to freshen yourself and to soothe your skin.

As a result, the skin will benefit from the active ingredients, and the smell may fade after a while.

Both items have the same foundation. Colognes and aftershaves are marketed by certain producers as the same product.

However, the scent of an aftershave lotion does not remain as long as that of a cologne.

What Is Virgin Island Bay Rum Aftershave?

As we’ll see, sailors governed the Virgin Islands and their waterways in the 16th century.

For months, bearded sailors sailed the seas. So they went without bathing for months.

Imagine how bad those ships smell! Some sailors went out to fix the stink. Some sailors claimed West Indian bay tree leaves smelt good. Pressing the leaves on their skin to release the scent also helped.

But it made the ship more comfortable, not a miracle cure. Using molasses to make sugar, slaves invented rum.

They drank rum, a byproduct of sugar processing.

A sailor distilled the formula and made it 10x stronger. Bay rum was created by extracting essential oils from bay leaves.

Also Read: The 10 Best Stubble Trimmers of 2022 | Reviews

Conclusion!

Take a break from the stresses of the day-to-day to pamper yourself with a soothing wet shave, even in the modern world.

To top it all off, we’ve got aftershave to keep you smelling fresh for a few hours while also soothing your sore muscles.

Captain’s Choice Bay Rum is our top pick from the 10 rums mentioned above. It’s a slam dunk in every way.

To notify you where you’ve sliced too near, the alcohol concentration offers a nice burn.

Moreover, it reduces the effects of alcohol while keeping your skin hydrated.

There’s a traditional bay rum perfume here, with just the appropriate amount of additional spices to create a masculine and mature smell.

Furthermore, it’s not a burden on the pocketbook.

Leave a Comment